In 2005, Wyoming doctors succeeded getting the State Legislature to pass a bill requiring injured patients who want to file medical malpractice lawsuits to first file their claims with the Wyoming Medical Review Panel.  Physicians argued this panel was needed to stop frivolous medical malpractice lawsuits and to lower their malpractice insurance costs.

However, as reported in the Sunday, January 31, 2010, Cheyenne Wyoming Tribune-Eagle, the Wyoming Medical Review Panel has not lowered medical malpractice insurance costs.  One reason is that most Wyoming doctors, surgeons, radiologists, pathologists, nurses, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, hospitals, assisted living centers and nursing homes are waiving their rights to take the case to the panel.  They choose not to have the panel hear their side of the story. The Wyoming Medical Review Panel requires filing by patients alleging injury or death of a family member, but the health care providers do not have to file any defense.  Patients must hire expert witnesses to testify before the panel but doctors can merely opt out of the process. 

Opting out of the Medical Review Panel not only hurts doctors, it also hurts patients.  As noted in the article:

Cheyenne attorney Jim Fitzgerald said the medical view panel gives patients a chance to be heard. Opting out of the review process almost guarantees that the only way to resolve a claim is to go to court.

The review process allows patients to determine whether their case is strong enough to go to court. He said that in some cases, physicians were encouraged to settle if a panel of their peers criticized the care they had provided. Fitzgerald added that the original medical review panel also was more effective because doctors used it.

Jim Fitzgerald is more than willing to go to court but it is too bad for the patients with meritorious claims to not even get a hearing in front of the panel first.  For the panel process to work, everyone in the medical profession who has been blamed medical negligence needs to step up to the plate and present their side of the story to the Wyoming Medical Review Panel.